Treadstone1

Brandon Routh did a superb job as Superman. If you get Tom Welling to do it i don't think he will be able to carry it off, as his version of Superman was like a teeny bop kids version.A reboot isn't whats needed. Superman ain't Batman. If you think that you are missing the whole point of Superman. Routh should continue being Superman. If Warner's mess that up i will loose faith. Basically Routh is Superman and should be given a fair shot. He should do the next movie but with a more action packed . It would not be fair to cast him after one movie. He is and will continue to be a great Superman just like Chris Reeves was even though 3 and 4 were poor. If Warner's don't give Routh the next film it will all go wrong again just like when Donner was fired for no reason. Look what happened to the franchise after that it went down hill until Superman Returns. That film made over 4 million dollars so why is that considered a flop. The problem was before Singers version is that they spent so much money getting another version made and directors etc came and went Returns didn't really make a profit. That's Warner's fault not the fans so they should bring Routh back as a lot of fans like him for the part. For the record i thought Returns was a great film. No it wasn't like batman but that's good cause Supes isn't batman. If your a fan you should know that or as i previously said you are missing the point. Please Warner's don't get a new Supes keep Brandon.