TheJoker

Anyone whos thinking they should recast the joker in batman 3, do you think they should do a film purely based on the joker with a new actor portraying the joker and how he becomes who he is etc, then use that actor to star in batman 3 so the audiences have got used to the new joker? I dont know about you lot but id love to see more of the joker, heath did a great job, but the character is who he is and can be replaced, jack nicholson did a great job as the joker, but heath had the advantage in that this joker was now more darker and evil, where as jack nicholsons joker was alot more campier and not as scary, how do you feel about a purely joker film being made? I think it would be amazing personally, bring back the joker!!!!

totally agree with slysnide, if anyone took the time to read my comment properly they understand what I was getting at and similar points to slysnide, bring the joker back for a 3rd film

In my opinion they should the recast the joker - YES!!! For me and am sure other fans out there, the joker is what made the film so good, not the fact it was heath ledger(RIP) although may I add he did a great job, to me anyone could of done a great joker, BECAUSE this batman was so dark and the joker was more mature and alot more serious, for me it was the joker not who played him who made it for me, so I feel they need to bring him back for a 3rd, look at the sales of the film so far compared to batman begins, my opinion it was the joker who sold them it, not many people would of thought about heath ledger as the joker but played it well, but lets not look at the bigger picture, yes he did a great job BUT someone like johnny depp could fill his shoes and other great actors out there, because this joker is alot more darker and serious compared to maybe jack nicholsons joker, although again played amazingly was a bit camp and not very scary etc, you want a good batman listen to the fans and bring the joker back, other rivals like catwoman, penguin, mr freeze to me are just to comical and not taken very seriously, the riddler on the other hand could be like jigsaw in saw, where he leaves traps and riddles around obviously without the gore effect though that saw has, but leaves alot of explosives, traps, puzzles and leaving the audience what he'll do next, bring back the joker and if need be bring in the riddler, even like batman begins make a film on how the joker became who he is and set during batman begins or before it, to then introduce the joker back into the 3rd film, to make a top batman film, please bring the joker back, as they say the show must go on!!!

In my opinion they should the recast the joker - YES!!! For me and am sure other fans out there, the joker is what made the film so good, not the fact it was heath ledger(RIP) although may I add he did a great job, to me anyone could of done a great joker, BECAUSE this batman was so dark and the joker was more mature and alot more serious, for me it was the joker not who played him who made it for me, so I feel they need to bring him back for a 3rd, look at the sales of the film so far compared to batman begins, my opinion it was the joker who sold them it, not many people would of thought about heath ledger as the joker but played it well, but lets not look at the bigger picture, yes he did a great job BUT someone like johnny depp could fill his shoes and other great actors out there, because this joker is alot more darker and serious compared to maybe jack nicholsons joker, although again played amazingly was a bit camp and not very scary etc, you want a good batman listen to the fans and bring the joker back, other rivals like catwoman, penguin, mr freeze to me are just to comical and not taken very seriously, the riddler on the other hand could be like jigsaw in saw, where he leaves traps and riddles around obviously without the gore effect though that saw has, but leaves alot of explosives, traps, puzzles and leaving the audience what he'll do next, bring back the joker and if need be bring in the riddler, even like batman begins make a film on how the joker became who he is and set during batman begins or before it, to then introduce the joker back into the 3rd film, to make a top batman film, please bring the joker back, as they say the show must go on!!!