YOUR SUMMER MOVIE SUCK$: Does the A-Team Jump the Shark or Nuke the Fridge?

Does the A-Team suck?
Does the A-Team suck?
Billy Appleton with you once again, here on this sweltering June day. I'm sweating so much, you might think me a basement dwelling tweeb who just asked his first girl out on a date (not true!) But I do need some air conditioning up in this attic, so I might crawl down and visit the local Cineplex for a cool breeze, an icy soda, and an epic summertime big screen extravaganza. Are our movies still sucking? Let me check...

It's the sixth big summer release weekend of 2010, and we've yet heard nary a critic bestow any of our previously released blockbuster outings with that coveted cliché: "It's the thrill ride of the summer!" That might all change with this Friday's debut of director Joe Carnahan's version of The A-Team.

Yes! It's a TV adaptation. Yes! We've seen it all before. But that trailer is a kicking scream of juvenile bliss. And that scene with the falling tank is tits. Wait! What's that you say? There's not another scene like it in the whole movie? The A-Team is a bland hassle that hustles up an origin story we used to get in two minutes during the opening credits of the TV show? That this is to TV adaptations what last May's Robin Hood was to that particular legend. An unnecessary BM plunked in the PM? Gosh darned it! I so didn't want the The A-Team to suck. Sorry folks, but that's the word on the street.

As I do every week, I checked out all of my favorite on-line reviewers to hear what they had to say about The A-Team. I haven't seen it yet. I seriously wanted to. Because it looked like a lot of fun. Oh, how these critics have damped my spirits. Sorry Guys and Gals? It sucks! (And remember, you can check out the full review by clicking on the provided link)

USA TODAY's Claudia Puig:


"There's nothing exciting about this awful, over-the-top reboot. Instead of quickening our pulses, it makes our eyes glaze. Rarely more than bloated and boring. Neither the comedy nor the stunts and effects make for much fun. we get wooden acting. It's hard not to pity the fools who spend their dollars on this overblown mess."


Roger Ebert:


"An incomprehensible mess with the 1980s TV show embedded inside. At over two hours of Queasy-Cam anarchy, it's punishment. Bored out of my mind during this spectacle, I found my attention wandering to the subject of physics. No action in this movie necessarily has any relationship to the actions surrounding it. How is it interesting to watch a movie in which the "action" is essentially colorful abstractions?"


Film Freak Central's Walter Chaw:


"Has not one spark of inspiration in its creation. An expensive knock-off of a kitschy cultural artifact. A picture for stupid people. (The A-Team) engage in hopelessly convoluted rififi. Neophytes will find a gay(er) Charlie's Angels mash-up involving a band of cartoon Rescue Rangers doing impossible things to physics in a celebration of being an all-American doorknob."


IESB's Jeff Otto:


"What's missing is the fun of the old series. Gone is the sense of whimsy of the original (TV show). This new The A-Team focuses entirely on the origin of the Alpha Unit. It spends its time on the serious tip, trying to explain everything and never really loosening its shirt collar all the way. There's a completely unnecessary conflict about the Mohawk. Mr. T had a Mohawk, no explanation necessary. It's just not really The A-Team. It's just too bad that after all these years of revisions and revamps they never really got it."


The Boston Globe's Wesley Morris:


"Lifeless and unneeded. The excitement is lost in a spree of terrible editing and a plot that not even your being the screenwriter could make you care about. (It) coasts on expensive-looking, sloppily executed action sequences that fall well short of standard kinetic mayhem. They're not making a movie. They're making a franchise."


Chicaqgo Reader's Cliff Doerksen:


"Pithy descriptions don't come easy after a brain-fragmenting experience like this movie version of the unaccountably popular TV show. The convoluted plot and multiple villains may challenge the attention span of the target demographic. Liam Neeson phones it in as smirking squad leader Hannibal Smith."


Joblo's Chris Bumbray:


"Yet another disappointment, in a summer full of them. The film grinds to a halt once we're introduced to the incredibly lame villain. The A-Team falls apart in the second hour. The McGuffin of the plot, being a bunch of counterfeit plates, is as boring as can be. I was surprised at how badly the fight scenes were done, with this being yet another film where the hand to hand action is indecipherable due to too much quick cutting, and too many close-ups. A major disappointment."


There you have it folks. Like I said, The A-Team just isn't very good. And it certainly doesn't deserve our cash. Though I hear The Karate Kid isn't worth your time either. Gosh darn it, it sucks too!

The A-Team was released June 11th, 2010 and stars Liam Neeson, Bradley Cooper, Jessica Biel, Quinton Jackson, Sharlto Copley, Patrick Wilson, Gerald McRaney, Henry Czerny. The film is directed by Joe Carnahan.



Sources: Billy Appleton

Do you like this story?


RELATED STORIES

BEST OF THE WEB

Comments (24)

  1. CelluloidDreams

    I was surprised by the "A-Team"!!

    I grew up with the Tv show, and I really had no interest in the film. But W./a crappy Summer so far, (I.E. "Iron Man 2"!) ...I went and plucked down $5.50 and saw "A-Team" .... The "A-Team" takes everything that was fun about the series on which it was based and amps it up into stratospherically ridiculous heights, and it does so with an irresistible insouciance and absolutely no apologies!

    I would Give "A-Team": B-

    ! It just needed a better sound-track! Bradley Cooper was a trip! He gave great stand-out performance!

    Sharlto Copley as H.M. "Howling Mad" Murdock ..gave another interesting perforance to his resume since "District 9" (2009)

    Liam Neeson as John "Hannibal" Smith ...another good performance ... Very sutle

    3 years agoby @2movieguysFlag

  2. CelluloidDreams

    ..I also agree W./I AM FRATSON ... I dont give 2 sh*ts what any critic gives a movie. i judge for myself ...end of story ...most critics are paid to watcha film...and never really enjoy a film!!!

    3 years agoby @2movieguysFlag

  3. I AM FRATSON

    @jimthar - i agree. i loved the ateam. not gonna win any awards but it was EXACTLY what i wanted from a summer movie. Im hoping they do a sequel.

    @fallen - agree with you on robin hood. i really liked the entire direction of the movie and hope to god they make the sequels and continue the story. it ended perfectly.

    as for billy. you are an idiot. i dont give 2 sh*ts what any critic gives a movie. i judge for myself since 80% of the time you guys have it wrong anyways. you obviously dont know your audience, let alone anything about the movie. any dumbass could do your job better.

    3 years agoby @iamfratsonFlag

  4. Jimthar

    sorry but i just saw this movie last night (7/5/10) and it was f*cking awesome. i dont know what this douchebag 'reviewer' is on but this movie totally kicked ass. it was a lot of fun to watch. not only did it have me laughing but the action scenes were stunning and left me on the edge of my seat. this guy needs to get the stick out of his ass. seriously. a-team was a really fun popcorn movie and i really hope they do another one. pure action movie fun. go see it if you haven't already.

    3 years agoby @jimtharFlag

  5. Mutant

    Seems to me he isn't bothered with each and every film , that he's relying on others to do his job. This article shows how much he doesn't care about his career nor is he getting in some good reviews.

    3 years agoby @zenderFlag

  6. Jason27

    I'm getting seriously pissed off with this Billy idiot. All I ever see are negative comments and reviews from him, and they aren't even HIS reviews!!! Screw you buddy, go see the movie, THEN judge! Pretty much every film gets some negative critique and all you seem to be focused on is that! If you're so cheap you cant even spend a few $$$ to go see a movie to review it, WHICH IS YOUR JOB (I'm guessing since you're a "reviewer") then you shouldn't be in this field. Get a life.

    3 years agoby @jason27Flag

  7. Rufio

    how does someone "REVIEW" something they haven't SEEN? isn't the point of being a critic to actually critique material, not spout off/rip off other people's words as your own (words and opinion)? fail.

    "As I do every week, I checked out all of my favorite on-line reviewers to hear what they had to say about The A-Team. I haven't seen it yet. I seriously wanted to. Because it looked like a lot of fun. Oh, how these critics have damped my spirits. Sorry Guys and Gals? It sucks!"

    3 years agoby @rufioFlag

  8. LuthorX

    because he hates this movie.. thats why

    3 years agoby @luthorxFlag

  9. Spongebob_Boxofficepants

    I don't really hate critics but why does this idiot has to put every critic with bad review
    It reminds me of Sanjaya

    3 years agoby @spongebob-boxofficepantsFlag

  10. The Dark Knight

    I liked it hah

    3 years agoby @thedarkknight23Flag

  11. Draktyr

    This is exactly why I don't listen to other people's opinions anymore. I reserve judgment for myself.

    3 years agoby @draktyrFlag

  12. u1sart

    It seems like Movieweb just happen to choose all the bad revisions of the movie and insert on their website. And i cant believe that no one had nuthing good to say about the A-team.. i am going to see it and karate kid anyway... I hate critiques, y i guess its because they talk what they dont like but give them the job to do better.. and they still cant compare...

    3 years agoby @u1sartFlag

  13. ed_wood

    This is always just a bashfest of the new movie of the week. I don't even know why I read it. But I will agree that The Hurt Locker was an amazing movie. The A Team will be good but don't walk in expecting anything close to the quality of Hurt Locker.

    3 years agoby @ed-woodFlag

  14. the Narrator

    @billyappleton, I know you're just doing your "job", but for every movie that you've had on this weekly report, you've scanned the internet and only managed to find bad reviews for them. Where as I have found numerous good ones for the same exact movies. I know bad news sells and all, and you're trying to show us if our summer movies really do suck (most of which do), which I thank you for, but try to be fair. Post some good tid bits up as well, so the weaker minds on the site can actually choose who to believe. I mean you reported that Robin Hood sucked, but I actually enjoyed it, as have many people on this site and many people I know. It wasn't great, but it was good. All the people who trust your article won't go and judge for themselves unless they really want to, so again, be fair.

    3 years agoby @narratorFlag

  15. the Narrator

    @Kman, I'm sorry, but The Hurt Locker was easily in the top five of last year, or should I say top three. Slow? Please, there are far slower movies out there... about 60% of them IMO. If you couldn't make your way through that so called overrated, boring film, then I would have to say stick to your witty action films. I mean calling it boring, when you obviously stayed put through the Lotr series and 300 (some of my favorites), all of which had some of the slowest down time scenes ever. You do that but call this movie boring? Doesn't make sense.

    Granted I agree with you at times on this site, but you can be found often to be too rash, and too critical on some movies, and not on others. Hurt Locker one of the greatest achievements in the cinematic war department in the past ten years. We can disagree, but at least find some solid points to back up your opinion. I mean, it was so under-hyped its not even funny. Out of all the nominees, IB and D9 were the only other solid choices. I mean no one in my friends or family heard of THL except me. It won because it was good while entertaining.

    I hate to talk about it here, since this is an A-Team article, but try and re-watch the movie with an open mind and you might see something. With respect, Fallen.

    3 years agoby @narratorFlag

  16. the Narrator

    I know your just doing your "job", but for every movie that you've had on this weekly report, you've scanned the internet and only managed to find bad reviews for them. Where as I have found numerous good ones for the same exact movies. For a lot of them the reviews are one-sided, usually in favor of it being rotten, and I agree, this summer seems less than meh. However, some of them are still pretty good. I would like to see some other reviews on here, besides the ones that best serve your purpose. Lets face it, you haven't had a single fully positive thing yet.

    3 years agoby @narratorFlag

  17. TheSilverfox24

    I saw this movie tonight and I thought it was awesome. The only thing i didn't like was Quinton Jackson as BA.

    3 years agoby @thesilverfox24Flag

  18. Justice23

    appleton go to hell
    i saw this today with a huge group of friends and we are all fans of the tv show and we enjoyed this movie alot

    3 years agoby @justice23Flag

  19. TheDude1

    Critics rarely like most popular movies. What is the difference this time? Nothing.

    3 years agoby @thedude1Flag

  20. Avian

    I liked it. No, it wasn't great, but it wasn't bad. Just a good action movie for the summer. Critics always try to look for something that isn't there, and when it isn't, it's instantly unwatchable for them.

    3 years agoby @avian005Flag

  21. Joser1500

    f*ck critic that say it sucks!! they could f*ck off thats right!!! it was great!!!

    3 years agoby @joser1500Flag

  22. K-Man

    Not surprised by the reviews considering this movie looks like it would top the charts for biggest piece of sh*t of this already terrible summer of movies.

    @ GreatOz - Not really sure what you mean when you say "walking into A-Team expecting another Hurt Locker" considering Hurt Locker is the most over-rated, boring, forgettable film of last year which by the way never should have even been nominated for any awards let alone won any. Got to love the politics involved in Hollywood.....what a joke.

    3 years agoby @k-manFlag

  23. GreatOz

    Anyone walking into the A-Team expecting another Hurt Locker should be deemed a waste of skin. These mindless movies are just that- mindless. But, sometimes people go to the movies to forget thier problems and escape. and these kind of movies may take our money but give us an escape. Just because some critics forgot that and they are trying to be the one with the funniest put-down, does not we have to listen. Let's make our own choices and feel free to knock it AFTER we have seen it.

    3 years agoby @greatozFlag

  24. Messenger

    Though this doesn't look to great, critics can eat a fat one. Saying "this movie is for stupid people"? What if someone just enjoyed and realized that it wasn't a great flick? I felt that Transformers 2 was not a good film but I enjoyed it because it was fun. I wish to God some of these critics would make a movie....they won't because they can't.

    3 years agoby @messengerFlag

(More)Recent Activity