'Trick 'r Treat' Review By JT's Movie Page

Trick 'r Treat Is Sure To Be The Next Big Cult Horror Film
  • Story
  • Acting
  • Directing
  • Visuals

By J.T. Johnson

Director: Michael Dougherty

Cast: Quinn Lord, Brian Cox, Dylan Baker, Anna Paquin

Producer Bryan Singer (“The Usual Suspects”) lets one of his “X-Men” writers, Michael Dougherty, make his feature-film directorial debut with “Trick ‘R Treat.” The movie explores four interwoven horror stories that take place on the same Halloween night. The result is one of the best horror films in recent years.

Originally slated for release in 2007, Warner Bros. pushed the film back and there were only a few small public screenings held for the film. Those screenings, however, created an underground buzz with internet film reviewers giving the flick an almost universally positive response.

How good the film is depends largely on the four stories told throughout the movie. First, the opening of the film shows a young couple calling it a night and the woman decides it is time to take the decorations down. Unknown to her, there is an unseen stalker watching her every move and has decided that she has not respected the holiday as much as she should have.

After this cold opening, the film takes off and tells the story of a principal (Dylan Baker) who is secretly a serial killer, a tale of a “virgin” (Anna Paquin) who is looking for the right guy and a story about five teens who pull a prank that goes too far.

The fourth and final story is about a bitter old man (Brian Cox) who is completely disgusted with everything associated with Halloween. While he scares little kids away from his house and watches infomercials to avoid Halloween programming, he begins to change his attitude after he encounters the trick ‘r treater from Hell known as Sam.

This film brings back what was great about classic horror films such as “Creepshow” and John Carpenter’s “Halloween.” This is because Dougherty knows the three basic ingredients to any horror film. Add one part creepy, one part horror and one part dark humor and he has a film that is destined to be a cult classic. It has scares of every kind including jump scares, creepy things in the shadows and outright gore.

The film has some genuinely dark yet funny moments such as when Principal Wilkins, played masterfully by Baker, tells his potential prey about the rules of Halloween. If someone doesn’t follow the rules, the spirits of the dead will come back to get you, Wilkins says. In this film, audiences better believe it.

What makes each of the stories great is that they start off with all of the clichés of a stereotypical ghost or slasher flick. Then, Dougherty puts a twist on each of the stories that make them stand above the rest. I would mention those twists here, but where would the fun be in that?

The best story in the film has to be that of Mr. Kreeg and his run-in with the ultimate trick ‘r treater, Sam. Sam is a kid that wears red jammies and apparently has an oversized head with a burlap sack over it. He never speaks and audiences immediately know that something’s not quite right with this kid. This little demon bastard pops up throughout the film observing the events that take place in the other stories as they unfold. He is like the god of Halloween that observes whether or not people are following the rules. When he finally begins to terrorize Kreeg, his true nature is revealed and one sees what happens when they don’t follow the rules.

What makes Sam a great villain is that he does not have an origin story. He is simply the boogeyman that doesn’t speak and has no real emotion. Sam deserves a place at the top with the likes of other horror movie icons such as Mike Myers or Pinhead.

The only real complaint there is with the film is that the story of the five kids pulling a prank is the weakest and most boring of the four stories. Certain elements of the story serve a purpose later in the film, but it is really the only moment where the film tends to drag.

It should also be noted that if you do not like seeing kids get hurt in films, do not watch this movie. Kids are fair game here and they do get hurt and maimed in the film. Surprisingly, it did not bother me here as it usually does in other movies, but still, I feel I must warn those who have weak stomachs towards children being harmed to stay away from this one.

In the end, this film is destined to become a Halloween tradition amongst horror movie fans. Also, Dougherty recently announced that he would like to make a sequel with four more stories. Here’s to hoping it will contain the return of Sam.

4 / 5 Stars – Very Good

Do you like this review?

Comments (8)

  1. JT's Movie Page

    You see, Newkill disagrees with how good or bad the film is, but at least he respects that I have my own opinion. By the way, Newkill, you also wrote a good review. August, it's not that I mind that you hate the film, it just seems that you are here to bash everyone who did like the film. You say you don't like the film, but you don't give any substantial reasons as to WHY you hate the film.

    I did not even know about the film or the hype surrounding it until I saw the film, so there is no way my judgment could be clouded by the hype. My friend, Josh (a guy I work with) told me about the film and said I should check it out. I did and ended up liking it. After I saw the film, I went and looked up the history of the film's production because Josh told me it was supposed to be out in 2007.

    If you hate the film, fine, then write your own review... unless you just don't know what to say. In that case, respect the opinions of the people who do actually post their opinions and give the reasons WHY they like it.

    5 years agoby @johnjohnson7777Flag

  2. RavenX5 God of Light

    nice review, and yea the prank crap thing was very mediocre.

    5 years agoby @hackx9Flag

  3. Newkill3000

    Wow, penguin, no matter what review has been written you seem to try to bring my name up everywhere. I disagree with John but at least his review is great, you just wrote dumb sh*t. And funny how i was the one to write my review first and almost right after that you come up writing a half c*ck review. Don't criticize me, penguin, just because I'm the only guy that dislikes this movie.

    5 years agoby @newkill200Flag

  4. penguin_9026

    August we get the picture that you dont like the film. You have told everybody who has rated this high that they're biased but you running your mouth constantly proves that you're the one being biased. Quit trying to ruin the fun for others that like the film and those that have not seen it yet. If you want to dis this film go ahead but dis it with Newkill since you two magically agree on everything. Good review by the way.

    5 years agoby @penguin-9026Flag

  5. Comrade

    I'm sorry john, but it seems like there's only one user telling his real feelings about this film and not letting the hype surrounding this movie get to him. Sadly to say the hype has clouded your judgment.

    5 years agoby @august22Flag

  6. Twisted Smile

    Good review man. I loved this movie.

    5 years agoby @twistedsmileFlag

  7. JT's Movie Page

    Since you've seen the film and hate it so much, then why do you care what the rest of us have to say? If you want you're voice to be heard, write your own review.

    5 years agoby @johnjohnson7777Flag

  8. Comrade

    This review was not helpful at all. Simply because you seem to be to biased because of the hype surrounding this movie and you just bought into it without really looking at the big problems of the movie. The maximum stars this movie should get is at least a 2.5.

    5 years agoby @august22Flag