The Other Woman: Review By SCREENWRITER

Natalie Portman does it again giving a performance as realistic as they come! This may have topped her work in "Black Swan".
  • OVERALL
    4.5
    SUPERB
  • Story
  • Acting
  • Directing
  • Visuals
"The Other Woman" is one of the most dramatic, emotional films I've seen since last year's "Rabbit Hole". With a plot almost similar, the two movie's have plenty of differences. This film makes me appreciate all my stepmother has done for me in the past, and it makes me very guilty for the way I've treated her as well. With a script that complicates the bonds between a stepmother and stepson, "The Other Woman" stands as the best film of 2011 thus far.

The film may seem like it has a little storyline, simple enough, but it grasps enough backround of all of the characters to make it a bit more complex. The movie works in a line of switching between past moments and present moments showing us how the characters got to the point where they are. Meet Emelia, she's married to Jack, a divorced man with an eight-year old son, William. William is just as complicated as Jack's annoying ex-wife Carolyne and Emelia does all she can to win the affection of William, even though it always turns out bad. With that complicated situation in Emelia's life, she also faces a recent trajedy, the death of her and Jack's newborn baby Isabel, who only lived for three days. With a struggle to find love from William, it only complicates Emelia and Jack's relationship more and she soon finds herself alone in her emotions.

Natalie Portman does it again! Her performance as Emelia is just as fantastic as her latest performance was in "Black Swan", if not better. In the past two months, Portman has released three different films, "Black Swan", "No Strings Attached", and this. She never seems to disappoint in any performance and there is no differance here. This is why Portman stands as one of the best actresses' of our time. Yes, I stand by that statement. Portman's character, Emelia, is as real as they come. Emelia's broken, but watching her trying to stand strong through the entire movie is heartbreaking. "The Other Woman" is a film in which actually does a great job with the crafting of each charac ter, all having a point, all having a situation they can't seem to solve.Lisa Kudrow ("Friends") plays a role unlike her usual genre. Normally playing the goofy, obnoxious type here she plays Carolyne, while still obnoxious but very serious about everything as well. Before seeing the movie I never imagined Kudrow to do as well as she did and I'm happy she proved me wrong. Charlie Tahan, playing eight-year old William reminded me of the kid from "The Switch" in every scene he was in. His bright, know-it-all character with Portman's character was great and their chemistry was fantastic. Scott Cohen as Jack, Emelia's husband, also gives a solid performance. I'm not too familar with anything he's done from the past, but, I'd like to see him do more in the future.

Don Roos wrote and directed this film based off the novel by Ayelet Waldman. With a story that seems simple, Roos crafts it into something much more complicated than it could have been, which makes it much more marvellous. His skill with the dialog between Emelia and William is great and his mellow-dramatic scenes can be breath-taking. As for the direction, I loved Roos' shots of the city. His zoom-in shots were perfect and I loved his idea of having one scene in particular in split-screen using one frame for the past, present, and future. It made it all the more emotional and realistic. If your interested in other works from Don Roos, he directed 2005's "Happy Endings" and wrote 2008's "Marley and Me".

The film does a great job balancing humor with drama. It places dry-humor when most needed especially in the scenes between William and Emelia. While their scenes can sometimes be over-dramatic, they can also be hilarious, as well. I loved Emelia's sarcastic-wit to most of William's comments, being hilarious each time.

It normally takes alot for me to learn something from a movie. A lesson, I mean. Having growing up with a stepmother myself, "The Other Woman" did a fine job making me feel guility for the ways I treated mine growing up. My family didn't have the complications of getting through a newborn's death, but, like William, I'd do all I could to get my stepmother in trouble with my father and never care at all. Before watching this movie I'd never think it'd take a toll on my childhood and had me thinking of something I'd never think I'd care about today.

Overall, "The Other Woman" is a fantastic little movie that stands as the best film of 2011 thus far. It's fantastic script brings out the best of each actor in the film making it feel more real. This is a movie that doesn't deserve to be looked away from and it not getting a wide-release is a mistake because I know it could have sucedded more. It sure deserved it.

Thanks for the read!

-Screeny

Do you like this review?

Comments (24)

  1. SCREENWRITER

    @Daveactor7: Oh, okay. haha. I don't remember what color the leaves were :p For half the movie I thought it was taking place in Boston for some reason.

    @Supes: That name has a real ring to it. :D

    1 year agoby @the-screenwriterFlag

  2. Daveactor7

    @Screeny in the movie of course lol

    1 year agoby @daveactor7Flag

  3. Dan

    Natalie F. Portman :P

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  4. SCREENWRITER

    @Daveactor7: Wait...are you talking about how they looked in this movie...or is that just a random statement? lol :P

    1 year agoby @the-screenwriterFlag

  5. SCREENWRITER

    Lmao. Its official then. MW will have to edit her name.

    1 year agoby @the-screenwriterFlag

  6. Daveactor7

    What stood out to me a lot since im a new yorker-the leaves are still green when its winter lol

    1 year agoby @daveactor7Flag

  7. Dan

    It rolls off the tongue nicely.

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  8. The Narrator: The Better Man

    Ahaha @Screeny. That does sound hot, and a bit weird. :P

    1 year agoby @narratorFlag

  9. SCREENWRITER

    @Supes: Nope. Unless I see this again and want a change then I won't change the rating. haha. F*cking should be her middle name. It suits her. :D

    God, that sounded bad saying outloud...:/

    1 year agoby @the-screenwriterFlag

  10. Dan

    Is this another one who's score will continually drop for you after a couple days? :P Joking, just like giving you sh*t about that lol.

    It'll definitely be a rental for me, but you can be sure I'll see it eventually. It's got Natalie F*cking Portman.

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  11. SCREENWRITER

    @The Narrator: The movie is already avalible for rent on Comcast OnDemand for 7 bucks. :D And yeah, I forgot about the film's score. It actually had a pretty good one too that played in a few scenes. I'll edit that in. :P

    1 year agoby @the-screenwriterFlag

  12. The Narrator: The Better Man

    Good job Screeny. I like that you covered everything (well, except the films score). I wasn't going to watch this, but I feel it might strike a chord with me as well. A rental for sure.

    1 year agoby @narratorFlag

  13. SCREENWRITER

    @llikePie202: I didn't actually go see it. I rented it OnDemand which is well worth it. :D Thanks, anyway.

    1 year agoby @the-screenwriterFlag

  14. IlikePie202

    nice review! I'm skipping it though, because besides you, I havent heard anything good about it. And, the trailers did not catch my interest. I'll probably see Unknown, then Rango, than Battle LA

    1 year agoby @Ilikepie202Flag

  15. SCREENWRITER

    ha. Why thank you. Again, hopfully I'll have my rant of the new Mechanic up tonight. :D

    1 year agoby @the-screenwriterFlag

  16. Diaigma

    Good man. Never let people dictate your choices ;)
    Your view on 5 stars - couldn't have said it better myself!

    1 year agoby @diaigmaFlag

  17. SCREENWRITER

    @Diaigma: I didn't change it on your behalf :P I was back and forth in my mind to what I should rate it beforehand. And if your not sure about giving a movie 5 stars or not then it automatically doesn't deserve that rating. You shouldn't have to question a perfect movie so...thats why I changed it. lol

    1 year agoby @the-screenwriterFlag

  18. Daveactor7

    @Screeny lol true.

    1 year agoby @daveactor7Flag

  19. Diaigma

    You didn't have to change your rating on my behalf :P
    I know there are some I'd like to go back and change from my earlier reviews, before I keened by criticism. 4.5? I can settle with that. Then again you're looking at the likes of me and @geek who treasure the 5 star rating :P

    1 year agoby @diaigmaFlag

  20. SCREENWRITER

    @Diaigma: Well, I loved it. But, I've already moved this down to 4.5 stars. Still fantastic, though. I hope you see it. lol. And as you mentioned on my last review, it is time for a rant. Hopfully I'll have my review of "The Mechanic" up tonight.

    1 year agoby @the-screenwriterFlag

  21. Diaigma

    This struck a cord with you it seems, which surprises me. General reviews for this haven't been very good (36% so far). Nice review, but I doubt it's THAT good. No doubt on Portman's part, though :)

    1 year agoby @diaigmaFlag

  22. SCREENWRITER

    @Daveactor7: Thanks, man. But bland?! Well, to each his own. Normally, movies that aim to hit the heart get to me. And I loved Portman so that was a good blend. lol

    1 year agoby @the-screenwriterFlag

  23. Daveactor7

    Great review, but eh I thought this film was just kind of bland.

    1 year agoby @daveactor7Flag

  24. SCREENWRITER

    Yup, my past four reviews have been 5/5 stars. It's time for a rant, folks.

    1 year agoby @the-screenwriterFlag