The Iron Giant: Review By moviegeek

"Hogarth? That's an embarrassing name! Might as well call him Zeppo or something."
  • OVERALL
    4.5
    SUPERB
  • Story
  • Acting
  • Directing
  • Visuals
Set in the politically-frightened world of the late 1950s, The Iron Giant tells the story of a humongous robot from outer space that lands off the coast of Maine. It was in this time period, in the rising tensions of the Cold War, that America was most fascinated (and terrified) with aliens from outer space and nuclear war. In the film, the townsfolk are hesitant to believe the outrageous claim of a giant robot. The Government is equally unconvinced, but Kent Mansley, an agent for the Government, jumps on the story, desperate to destroy this 'thing'.

Enter Hogarth Hughes, a young boy just growing into his adult teeth. The boy has a knack for finding wacky pets and trying to give them new homes, but none of them come close to the monstrosity that he finds in the woods. After he sees the gigantic robot destroy a power station, he figures no one will believe him. As Hogarth attempts to capture the robot in a picture, his terror turns to fascination. The robot begins to act inquisitively towards his actions. Hogarth is shocked to find out that he can communicate with the giant. Hogarth immediately begins to freak out. He, essentially, has befriended a giant alien robot!

The animation for this picture is astonishing--not because it's groundbreaking, but because of how perfectly it fits. The film looks more like a cartoon than a feature length, theatrical release, but it looks just right. The colors are bright and spirited; the animation is quick and sharp; the movements are smooth and unrestrained. The technology doesn't upstage the material behind it.

Director Brad Bird (who nowadays is wildly known for his work with Pixar's Ratatouille and The Incredibles) meticulously works through every scene to make it perfect. Each gesture and emotion transitions well with each scene. Never are there random outbursts of emotion (except with Hogarth's prayer at dinner--hilarious). Each character grows steadily. The film builds upon what has been established already without retreading information and feelings.

The Iron Giant is a multi-layered film that works on every level. First and foremost, it's a story about friendship. The whole film moves and flexes on the basis of this friendship. It starts softly, with the two associating and learning about each other. Then it picks up speed as the two experience new things together. The friendship reaches its essence with their sacrificial love and care for each other.

On a completely different level, the film works as a political parallel. How do we, as a people, react towards the different, the extreme? We just want to get rid of it. We like our security and we don't want risk losing it. Those two elements work for older audiences who recognized the political angles and have built longer friendships. But there is another layer that really works well for the younger audiences it is targeting--loneliness.

Hogarth is not popular. He has no friends. He has no father. His imagination is so wild that many kids just think he is weird. When he meets the Giant, something sparks between them. Both he and the Giant feel alone. No one truly gets them. As their friendship blooms, Hogarth grows individually as well. He begins to learn how their friendship isn't built on how they are similar, but instead, how they are different.

Take, as an example, the very best scene in the movie. It comes when the Giant first understands what death is. A deer is shot in the woods and the Giant kneels over and tries to awaken it. Hogarth tells him there is nothing he can do. We see the sadness in the Giant's eyes. He feels helpless and vulnerable. The scene immediately morphs into a hint at the Giant's true purpose, but what precedes that is perfect. The Giant and the boy learn and feel things together, both good and bad. But it's when the Giant feels most helpless, when HE is powerless, that he tightens the bond with the boy.

That was what Hogarth was missing. He felt that he couldn't find any friends because no one was like him and that, therefore, no one would like him. But by the film's end, he, and hopefully the younger viewers as well, learn that friendship isn't based on looking for similarities, but filling in the differences. You owe it to yourself to watch this gem of a film. In fact, watch it twice.

Do you like this review?

Comments (26)

  1. XxNickTheFilmCriticXx

    @daveactor7 -- I saw the movie again about a year or two ago. It was a few years since I watched it, so I kind of forgot about the impact it had on me. That scene was also emotional for me, but I really liked the ending. It was nice, and I would've begged them for a sequel.

    But, 'The Iron Giant' is too good for a sequel.

    5 months agoby @XxNickTheFilmCriticXxFlag

  2. moviegeek

    Oh dang! @Yentz Alrighty I'll put it on my to-do.

    1 year agoby @moviegeekFlag

  3. Diaigma

    I agree. Worth checking out.

    1 year agoby @diaigmaFlag

  4. Bryan Yentz

    Yeah, it's definitely worth checking out because it has cool, creative visuals and tried to recapture the maturity of kid's films like Land Before Time and Fern Gully. One protagonist in it outright snaps another main character's neck guerrilla style.

    1 year agoby @bryanyentzFlag

  5. moviegeek

    Hmm. Well maybe I'll check it out. I have a few other films of higher priority to see first though.

    Few meaning many :P

    2 years agoby @moviegeekFlag

  6. Dan

    Like a PG version of Heavy Metal, except with a more solid story. The ending made me roll my eyes big time, but the rest was pretty good.

    2 years agoby @dan1Flag

  7. moviegeek

    What's it like? Like comparison to another picture? Is it just a special effects show, or..?

    2 years agoby @moviegeekFlag

  8. Dan

    Titan A.E. was decent. Not nearly as memorable, but entertaining in my opinion. But I'm a Sci-Fi lover, so of course I liked it.

    2 years agoby @dan1Flag

  9. moviegeek

    @Jake Hehe, awesome. Thanks!
    @Yentz Thanks a bunch :) I haven't seen that one. Worth it?

    2 years agoby @moviegeekFlag

  10. Bryan Yentz

    Great review, man. I love this movie... Haha, one of Vin Diesel's best performances... Now, who's gonna review Titan A.E.?

    2 years agoby @bryanyentzFlag

  11. Jakn

    I hardly remember most of this movie all because I haven't seent it since I was a little kid, but great review and actaully I was moved reading about the giant trying to wake up the deer.

    2 years agoby @jaknFlag

  12. moviegeek

    @Diaigma Thanks :) To get approval from you on a review for this is pretty significant, I'd say lol.

    2 years agoby @moviegeekFlag

  13. Daveactor7

    @Narzion of course he is :P

    2 years agoby @daveactor7Flag

  14. Diaigma

    Ah! You beat me to it! I was going to review this eventually. Awesome review, and I totally agree to your rating and insights :)

    2 years agoby @diaigmaFlag

  15. Dan

    Can't wait to see what he does with Ghost Protocol! :D

    2 years agoby @dan1Flag

  16. moviegeek

    @Narizon He really does!

    2 years agoby @moviegeekFlag

  17. Narzion

    brad bird RULES!

    2 years agoby @narzionFlag

  18. Daveactor7

    I was close to tears when the giant blows up with the bomb, but then i became happy when his pieces found their way back to his head

    2 years agoby @daveactor7Flag

  19. Dan

    Great review, classic movie.

    2 years agoby @dan1Flag

  20. moviegeek

    Thank you :) you ought do that.

    2 years agoby @moviegeekFlag

  21. Wichy

    Wow, great review. It was very in depth and it has been a long time since I have watched this, but now I think I should give it another watch :D

    2 years agoby @wichitagalzlFlag

  22. moviegeek

    Haha I know. I wassurprised to find it was him voicing it later.

    2 years agoby @moviegeekFlag

  23. Daveactor7

    "I go." "No...following" I have to say Vin Diesel is a better voice actor then he is in real life

    2 years agoby @daveactor7Flag

  24. Worth5Bucks

    Nice review. I love this movie. Its fantastic

    2 years agoby @mattbierwagenFlag

  25. moviegeek

    Awesome! thanks @Dave :D

    2 years agoby @moviegeekFlag

  26. Daveactor7

    I fully agree with this review and its going on my fave reviews list

    2 years agoby @daveactor7Flag