Oldboy: Review By Dan

Even though I'm no more than a monster - don't I, too, have the right to live?
  • OVERALL
    4.5
    SUPERB
  • Story
  • Acting
  • Directing
  • Visuals
Think about one of the sickest, most twisted movies you've ever seen. Now, put them out of your mind, and enter Oldboy's world. It is rare that I find a film that so disgusts me, yet intrigues me at the same time the way that this film does. South Korean director Park Chan-wook's 2nd installment (and the most well known and recognized) in his "The Vengeance Trilogy", is crafted in such a way that you feel compelled to finish it, no matter how grotesque the details become (and they do, this is some lurid, taboo material), as you learn the most shocking secrets only in the film's final 15 minutes, where everything comes together and clicks for you, in a way that will leave you highly disturbed.

Businessman Oh Dae-su (Cho Min-sik) is a blabbermouth. We're immediately shown this as he's being detained in a police station for a drunken brawl, and his somewhat amusing antics through brief clips of him waiting for his friend Joo-Hwan (Ji Dae-han. I'm having a blast here trying to spell all their names correctly...) to bail him out. As Dae-su makes a phone call to his daughter on her birthday, he then hands the phone to Joo-Hwan, and as Joo-Hwan turns around to hand the phone back, he discovers that Dae-su has disappeared. We then follow Dae-su's imprisonment in a hotel room that lasts for 15 years. Yes, 15 years. As he goes through the various stages of mental breakdowns and regrets, we are given glimpses of those who imprisoned him, and the conditioning they are doing to him. After the 15 years are up, he is suddenly released into what at first appears to be a grassy field, but as the camera pans to a different angle, it's actually the rooftop of a high rise (I love when movies mess with you like that). From there, Dae-su begins his quest of discovering why he was kidnapped and whom is responsible, in what simply becomes grosser but more enthralling as the film progresses.

I believe the thing about Oldboy that attracts many, despite its subject matter being about as taboo as you can get (incest is a prominent theme), is that we're told nothing about Dae-su's kidnapping or the motives behind it, and while the actual kidnapped segment only covers about 20 minutes of the film, there is more psychology hard at work during those 20 minutes then most entire films I've seen. Dae-su is at first content to just do nothing, and then attempting suicide (which is prevented by gas being leaked into his room to make him unconscious each time he tries, conditioning him to being unable to kill himself). He begins to find comfort in his television, absorbing all that he sees on it since it is his only connection to the outside world. By the time he is released, he has already gone through an impressive character arc by any movie's standards, and we're left to put the puzzle pieces together the same as he is over who is a friend, and who is an enemy.

In a way, this felt like a Korean version of Christopher Nolan's "Memento", in that we're introduced to all the characters fairly quickly, but whatever immediate perceptions we have of them are most likely incorrect. Park's method of slowly revealing the magnitude of each player's actions and reactions to different events is brilliant. By the time you've reached the film's climax inside antagonist Woo-jin's penthouse (Yu Ji-tae), you've learned that Dae-su is no innocent bystander, even though the film is rooted firmly around his 'vengeance'. Certainly any film student's delight in trying to unravel all the techniques used to keep one guessing, and I see why it is so critically acclaimed.

What was also fascinating to me is it seems like the Korean culture is similar to the U.K.'s, in that there is an ever sense of 'quiet desperation' with its people. If you pay attention to the commercials and shows Dae-su watches during his imprisonment, you see how goofy and cheerful the people seem, but this is all a lie. Many of the characters talk at lengths about killing themselves (including the antagonist, which felt very odd to me, considering he was the mastermind behind this long, drawn out revenge scheme of his against our... hero?), and it seems like behind those polite smiles everyone puts on, is a deep seated self loathing and longing for companionship. Maybe Park was trying to emulate the feeling some of us sense when we live in large cities surrounded by people, and yet feel so disconnected. Whether that was one of the feelings he was going for or not, it was a definite thought I had while viewing the film, which I suppose adds to its thoughtful structure.

It should also be noted that Oldboy ignores a lot of typical archetypes. Our villain is certainly.... villainous in his actions towards Dae-su, but in a way he is seeking revenge in much the same way as Dae-su is for what was done to him. I felt a morsel of pity and sadness for Woo-jin, as everything that occurs in the film began with a single, irreversibly damaging action by him, that wouldn't have mushroomed into what it did had it not been for Dae-su and his big mouth. So though Dae-su and Woo-jin fill their roles respectively, neither can clearly be classified as hero or villain. Torture is another theme that will be running through your mind, both figuratively, and literally, as they are both tortured souls inflicting wounds on one another.

And while Nolan's Memento didn't feature too much in the way of action (it was more talky, which I'm not slamming, especially since the dialogue is intelligent and thought provoking there, as well), Oldboy certainly has its share. There is a sequence in the film where Dae-su has just finished 'interrogating' one of his captors, and as he's trying to leave the building, the hallway is filled to the brim with those who would stop him. We watch him fight off all of his attackers using a claw hammer (ouch), but the camera pans along the wall as if it were a side scrolling video game you're watching. I thought that was a neat trick. When violence 'is' forwardly used in Oldboy, it is wince-inducingly graphic, to say the least. But what would an Asian film be without some martial arts and ass kicking? Exactly :P

Running just under 2 hours, and unfolding at an even pace that will keep you guessing and entertained (and revolted) til the end, Oldboy is the type of film that presents themes and images that are so left field that it is impossible to forget them once viewed. Seriously, I sort of wish I had a hypnotist to expel some of the knowledge I learned throughout the movie, but like a car accident, we can't stop looking, no matter how horrific it may be.

Do you like this review?

Comments (35)

  1. TheStonedReviewer

    Definitely want to see this!

    8 months agoby @stonedFlag

  2. John2347

    Good review. You should check out Chan-wook Park J.S.A. Joint Security Area Its a really brilliant movie.

    1 year agoby @john2347Flag

  3. Dan

    Again, my bad :P

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  4. slysnide

    You made it sound as if it'd be a while before you watched it.

    1 year agoby @slysnideFlag

  5. Dan

    My bad, I just figured you'd be on the look out for it next time you logged on since we discussed it. I guess that was my hubris at work :P

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  6. slysnide

    Dude, why didn't you tell me you reviewed this??? :P

    Damn, I've known of this for 7.5yrs, and have yet to see it. But I agree with your summation of these types of films and filmmakers.

    1 year agoby @slysnideFlag

  7. Dan

    @Yentz Cool, man, thanks. Yep, this was a good one.

    @Worth I understand, I feel the same way about @Moviegeek's, they can be great, quicker reads. I don't spit out reviews as quick as some people on here, so when I do, I try to make them a good length.

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  8. Worth5Bucks

    Fantastic review! I really want to see this now. I think youre my overall second favorite reviewer. Right behind Moviegeek. I enjoy reading both of your reviews equally but moviegeeks are generally a bit shorter so i can read his on the fly.

    1 year agoby @mattbierwagenFlag

  9. Bryan Yentz

    This is one of my all-time favorite films, and I couldn't agree more: Spielberg should leave his filthy hands off of this--you can't remake perfection. Awesome review, Supes.

    1 year agoby @bryanyentzFlag

  10. Dan

    Against. As much as I love Spielberg, this is one of those films that should just be left alone. Park's version is fine by itself.

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  11. The Narrator: The Better Man

    What'd you think of the news of Spielberg redoing Oldboy, Supes? Were you for or against it (my guess is against), before it was dropped?

    1 year agoby @narratorFlag

  12. Messenger

    @Supes

    Yeah man, that is some heavy stuff to take in but if it were me, I'd be in double pissed overdrive mode. It just didn't sit well with me when he did what he did. I just didn't like it. It didn't ruin the movie but it did kinda make me hate the character a little bit. But the twist was excellent!

    1 year agoby @messengerFlag

  13. Dan

    I love other cultures, most of the time more so than my own. I'd be perfectly comfortable living in a foreign country and being a foot taller then everybody else :P

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  14. Daveactor7

    @Supes lol yup
    However strange thing is Im korean but I look really...caucasian O.o and I do not have a caucasian background lol.
    You hit the culture spot on, despite what race you are, Im glad you understood it. Most ppl nowadays dont :P

    1 year agoby @daveactor7Flag

  15. Dan

    I know @DrCarter is black, which I find pretty cool, cuz he's a comic book dork like the rest of us. Not sure about others ethnicity, unless they say so.

    Me, I'm just plain ol' whitey white.

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  16. The Narrator: The Better Man

    Lol, I love how we all have our favorite reviewers on the site. And you're Korean @Dave? Cool, man. I think Zany is Chinese, while I'm your average white dude with a bit of Filipino from my moms side... felt like I could share that. :P

    1 year agoby @narratorFlag

  17. Dan

    @Dave Dude! I had no idea you were Korean. Cool, man. Glad you liked the review.

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  18. Daveactor7

    Being Korean, I loved your take on the culture. I felt this film was alright. But always and always @Supes you keep me thoroughly entertained with your reviews. You are easily the best reviewer on here :D

    1 year agoby @daveactor7Flag

  19. The Narrator: The Better Man

    That's cool @Supes. I look forward to the slew of good reviews. :)

    1 year agoby @narratorFlag

  20. moviegeek

    Great review man. i need to check this one out.

    1 year agoby @moviegeekFlag

  21. Wichy

    Great review @Supes. I have never watched this but I will surely give it a try. I especially liked your paragraph on Korean culture and the reality that all is not what it seems. Great job :)

    1 year agoby @wichitagalzlFlag

  22. Dan

    I'm trying to build up my review resume of lesser known, or independent films, as well. We're always inundated with the big, commercial movie reviews, somebody needs to represent the little guys :P

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  23. Dan

    @Narrator Of course :)

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  24. The Narrator: The Better Man

    Lol @Supes. I know you're not part a member of that whole hype thing. Your fantastic review is more than enough defense already. :) Lol. I was just saying that some people will do that with films like this, and I think if any of the below users see it, they should see it with their minds clear and free of hype and such, and enjoy it for what it is. I think you'd agree.

    1 year agoby @narratorFlag

  25. Dan

    @Narrator Well, in my defense, I only know of 2 other people that have seen this (besides you, now), and while they thought it was great, they didn't shove it down my throat to see it, so I wasn't part of the "hype" crowd. I just liked it for being an off the wall type movie I'd never seen.

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  26. The Narrator: The Better Man

    I very well done review at Supes. I especially liked your use of parenthesis as you used the properly and more in this review than any of yours I've seen yet. Good psychological analysis as well.

    However, I'm one of the few who saw the film, and didn't much care for it. It wasn't just awkward, it felt heartless at times, and the ending seemed to abrupt to tie everything up, especially after all the seemingly random or unorganized sh*t we just saw. Taboo would be the correct term for the film, as it was... yeah. Anyways, great review, but this film was one I found over-rated by the few who have seen it, like many secrets are. It's like some people see something that no one else they know has seen. They hype it up and say how great it is, and then when they get others to watch it, they all share the satisfaction of being some form of elite, and so on and so forth when really the secret (or film) wasn't that great to begin with.

    Not accusing you or anyone here of this, as you have written a fine and strongly legitimate review for the film. However, it does happen from time to time, and this film wasn't an exception for some. I found it unique and disturbing, but not quite what I'd like to see often. I'd give it a 4, and again, fantastic review.

    1 year agoby @narratorFlag

  27. SCREENWRITER

    Never heard of this one. Thanks for sharing it with me, man. Awesome review.

    1 year agoby @the-screenwriterFlag

  28. MovieWiz001

    Once again, a great review.

    1 year agoby @moviewiz001Flag

  29. Dan

    Although by that point in the film, he realizes what he did with the girl and the implications, so that was basically his mental meltdown and response to that. I somewhat can't blame him for the behavior, it's pretty f*cking extreme, you have to admit.

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag

  30. Dan

    @Messenger That was a bit off putting, but then it was saved by Woo-jin covering his mouth from laughing. Haha, that made me laugh, cuz that would be my reaction to that, too.

    1 year agoby @dan1Flag