Green Lantern: Emerald Knights: Review By Dan
When you shape the light of your ring, you walk in the footsteps of the first Lantern.
-
OVERALL4.5SUPERB
-
Story
-
Acting
-
Directing
-
Visuals
Lanterns: Nathan Fillion (pjwolsker's favorite actor), Elizabeth Moss, Jason Isaacs, Kelly Hu, Henry Rollins, Roddy Piper (Bolphunga!), Wade Williams, Arnold Vosloo
To those of you wanting to get more familiar with Green Lantern's mythos right before the live action film is released next week, this is essential viewing. You can pretty much skip watching First Flight, since the live action will cover Hal Jordan's origin, but Emerald Knights gives you good background on all the 'other' Lanterns, and the meaning behind the rings, constructs they can produce, and what it means to be a Green Lantern in the first place.
Though Emerald Knights isn't exactly accurate to the comics I've read, it's close enough to get it's points across. Instead of Lantern Ermey, who was Kilowog's drill instructor in Tales of the Corps, we've got Lantern Deegan, who is essentially the same character. I'm not sure why the name change, but it's fairly inconsequential. Just little changes of that nature. If one never picked up a GL comic in their life, these changes would make no matter to them anyways, but as a comic book reader myself, as I know a few others are on this site, I just wanted to give that fair warning.
While I'm normally more of a fan of one, movie length story compared to a bunch of anthology short stories, Knights manages to smoothly transition between a rookie Lantern Arisia and Hal Jordan, who regales her with legends of the Corps and it's more famous ring slingers, with what I felt the stand out story belonging to Lantern Laira. Having already read Kilowog's, Sinestro's, Abin Sur's origins, those didn't intrigue me as much as learning about Laira's obviously Japanese influenced alien culture. The stand out battle in the film has to be between Laira and her misguided father, and probably because a good deal of it takes place without ring slinging of any sort, just old fashioned martial arts beat downs. Mogo, who if you're not familiar with I won't ruin who 'he' is, would have the follow up place with his "altercation" with the warrior Bolphunga The Relentless. It at least got the biggest laughs from me. I'll refrain from describing the final segment of the film and leave that as a surprise, but I will say this: you will be intensely satisfied with the climax.
But like First Flight, I had the same minor complaint about the sound in Emerald Knights. It doesn't sound as crisp as some of the other DC Animated movies for an odd reason. I dunno if this was due to it not being made for 7.1 surround sound or what (it's 5.1), but it sounded rough to me. You'll notice this when the Lanterns fire their rings and listening to the space battles on your surround sound system (if you have one). I also felt the actor chosen to voice Sinestro (Jason Isaacs) seemed a little weak for such an egotistical character. I was excited initially about him voicing Sinestro, and that may have been partly due to being used to being able to see Isaac's naturally villainous face, but when you're hearing just his voice, it seemed to lose a lot of impact for me. Others may disagree on that point, but it's how I felt.
What is great about Emerald Knights, however, is the animation is mostly hand drawn, so it has that old school feel throughout, and only slightly enhanced with CGI for smoothness. I think I'll always be a fan of hand drawn versus complete CGI, at least for the foreseeable future until that technology improves. I loves me some old school cartoons (insert cheesy grin).
Much kudos to the rest of the voice cast, as well; Nathan Fillion makes for a perfect Hal Jordan (even wore a GL T-shirt during his recording sessions. That's how f*cking cool he is. Right, pjwolsker?), Moss made for a tolerable Arisia, and Rollins gave a distinctly different take on Kilowog (I think I've grown used to baritone voiced actors voicing him), that I quickly warmed up to. Kelly Hu was of course a natural Laira. Overall, besides Isaacs, this was a pretty great crew they picked out to give the Corps a voice.
That about sums this anthology feature up, folks. Rent it, buy it, steal your friend's copy, but do yourself a favor and see this before Warner Bro/DC's silver screen adaptation happens upon us in the very near future so that you can get on board and dork it up with the rest of us! (thedude-abides knows he wants to, deep down).
P.S.- To all of you comic readers, watch for the brief comments to events from the comic books. Something about a 'blackest night' or other.... :P And to ejk1: keep an eye out for a favorite 'red' guy.
Final Grade: A-

Comments (19)
To leave a comment, please sign in or use
Facebook or Twitter
the Narrator
Just saw this last week. Good job, @dan1. Humorous review, to say the least. I'd have to say that I enjoyed this film, and agree with all points. I'd give a 4, but that's still good. To this day my favorite animated feature length film concerning a superhero would be Batman: The Mask of the Phantom. That movie blew me away. Lol.
2 years agoby @narratorFlag
Summit10
this is way better film than First Flight...Nathan Fillion did find his way to be Hal after all! Very insightful review though there were changes like the first Lantern Avra rather than Rori Dag from the comic books at least it was easier to digest. Great read!
2 years agoby @summit10Flag
Dan
@corey They can't all tie for the number one spot, can they? No they can't :P. Red Hood can taken number 2 or 3.
2 years agoby @dan1Flag
Corey W.
@dan1 "thanks, dude. Yep, this was a great one. Possibly my favorite of the DC animated line up. It's a threeway tie between this, WW, and Apocalypse." No Red Hood in there?
2 years agoby @coreyFlag
Dan
@corey What about it?
2 years agoby @dan1Flag
Corey W.
@dan1 What about Under the Red Hood?
2 years agoby @coreyFlag
Zak Lee Ferguson
hahahaahahahahahahahahahahaahah good review hAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHA
2 years agoby @Zak-Lee-FergusonFlag
Pjwolsker
haha its all good @dan1
2 years agoby @pjwolskerFlag
Dan
@moviegeek Very funny. Not :P
@skywise thanks, dude. Yep, this was a great one. Possibly my favorite of the DC animated line up. It's a threeway tie between this, WW, and Apocalypse.
@ejk1 Yeah, I was surprised, myself... ah well. Thanks for the assist concerning First Flight
@slysnide Definitely let you know how the live action goes over.
@thedude-abides Without going into a bunch of details, Emerald Knights is easily the superior package with it's featurettes (on Blu Ray at least) and explaining the mythology of GL.
2 years agoby @dan1Flag
moviegeek
Teehee. can't wait to see how I like the reboot ;)
2 years agoby @moviegeekFlag
skywise
Awesome review, i really enjoyed this film too. Just watched it the other day in fact.
2 years agoby @skywiseFlag
slysnide
There always seems to be a slew of animated films related to the live action ones that debut right before the big release date. I still don't know about seeing GL in theaters. Probably won't actualy. Or I'll wait to hear the verdict from you @dan1.
2 years agoby @slysnideFlag
ejk1
Surprised that Isaacs disappointed you. He usually excels. Oh well, great review, @dan1
And to the uninitiated, Dan's right. Skip First Flight because it may ruin both the film next week and even subsequent sequels.
2 years agoby @ejk1Flag
Corey W.
Good one. I wanna review this one too but i'm not up for taking all the time to cook something up with my left hand lol
2 years agoby @coreyFlag
thedude-abides
@dan1 I knew this would garner some attention leading up to the release of Green Lantern. Here's a good question: Which supplement, if you will, to their respective movie served a better job painting a larger picture of the mythos?
I guess what I'm asking is, not which one was better in and of itself, but which type of format worked the best? Something like the Animatrix, where we're given a dvd's worth of short featurettes? Motion comics similar to the one for Inception? Or something like First Flight where it's one movie length story, but doesn't necessarily tie in to Green Lantern the way the other "supplements" might to their respective films?
2 years agoby @thedude-abidesFlag
MovieWiz001
Great, I'm not really into the animated Marvel and DC films, but I have seen Ultimate Avengers 1 and 2. Nice one, man. I might see this one day.
2 years agoby @moviewiz001Flag
Dan
@pjwolsker Every jab at you in the review is friendly, so don't freak out, bro :P
2 years agoby @dan1Flag
Diaigma
I better get me to this, stat! :D
2 years agoby @diaigmaFlag
Dan
@ejk1@narrator@diaigma@moviegeek@pjwolsker@corey@thedude-abides@skywise@slysnide@moviewiz001@SpaceCowboy@bawnian-dexeus @jpredskull @lane1
Emerald Knights, peoples.
2 years agoby @dan1Flag