To leave a comment, please sign in or use Facebook or Twitter
HBP wins my vote.
3 years agoby @cores717Flag
Where's the "I hate them both" button?
3 years agoby @squidmasterFlag
Ouch!!! I'll have to give it to HBP too; that was a little more faithful and didn't feel rushed. However, I'll give OOTP credit for being one of the petter HP films; the only problem was that the movie was rushed and some major events and parts of the book didn't make it into the film. That's WB's fault though, and not Yates, for not giving the film more time to add and flesh a few more things out; after POA and GOF, he was the best thing to happen to the HP series. But in the end, I enjoyed HBP much more; it's my second favorite in the series next to COS. 8)
3 years agoby @joker926Flag
These two are pretty much even in my books, but the edge goes to HBP, I guess, because it has such a sombre tone that the series needs towards its end.
3 years agoby @shuabertFlag